Object
South Norfolk Village Clusters Housing Allocations Plan (Reg. 19 Pre-submission Draft)
Representation ID: 2492
Received: 27/02/2023
Respondent: Collins & Coward Limited
Legally compliant? Not specified
Sound? No
Duty to co-operate? Not specified
The proposed allocation BAW1 is 1.4ha therefore contrary to Paragraph 69 of the NPPF.
Para. A5; Policy BAW1 - Not sound
The allocation of 35 units at Bawburgh (BAW1) is not sustainable. It will not enable the village to grow and thrive. The school is over-subscribed. The local doctors surgery, the Humbleyard Practice in Hethersett, is over-subscribed by 5,000 people. Bawburgh is not part of a cluster of nearby villages as confirmed by Council officers in their briefing to Parish Councils on 26.01.2023. Answer to Question 25: "The village is not clustered with others...". The allocation is unsound and fails para 79 of the NPPF.
Para. A7; Policy BAW1 - Not sound
The proposed allocation BAW1 is 1.4ha therefore contrary to Paragraph 69 of the NPPF.
Para. A13; Policy BAW1 - Not sound
The Bawburgh Primary School serves just the single parish of Bawburgh. It is over-subscribed. There is no capacity to extend the school and the proposed housing allocation could not viably fund any extension to the school.
Para. A27; Policy BAW1 - Not sound
The Council's assessment criteria fails to consider appropriate densities for propose sites. It suggests 25 units per hectare which is an urban densities not appropriate to rural allocations.
25 units are proposed on 1.4ha under BAW1. The most recent permission (2018/1550) was for 10 bungalows on 1.13 ha (i.e. 9 units per ha). BAW1 should be the same density of 9 units (bungalows) per hectare.
Para. A32; Policy BAW1
The sustainability assessment does not look at school, employment or health capacities in the villages.
Para. 6 - Not sound
Bawburgh is not part of a village cluster
Para. 6.3 - Not sound
The primary school has no capacity and is over-subscribed.
Para 6.5; BAW1 - Not sound
The site exceeds 1.0ha which is the upper limit as prescribed by para 69 of the NPPF. The new development of bungalows (10 units) permitted under 2018/1550 has a density of 9 units per hectare. BAW1 should be same density and comprise bungalows.
Para 6.6; BAW1 - Not sound
The proposed site has open views to and from the A47 contrary to para. 6.6
The form of any new development should respect the existing form of dwellings and village hall. New development should be bungalows.
Para 6.11; BAW1 - Not sound
Only 1 ha should be allocated at a density of 9 units per hectare. The development should be bungalows.
Policy BAW1 - Not sound
The design of dwellings should be bungalows to reflect form of existing development as the site is on the top of the plateau. Only 9 units to be developed on 1 hectare.
Modifications:
Allocation BAW1 -
Reduce site to 1.0ha
Max density 9 units per ha
Form of development to be bungalows
Yes, I do wish to participate in a hearing sessions.
It is essential to present evidence to show allocation BAW1 is unsustainable in terms of employment, education and health. The proposed allocation BAW1 is at inappropriate density add the site is too large. Bungalows rather than houses.
Support
South Norfolk Village Clusters Housing Allocations Plan (Reg. 19 Pre-submission Draft)
Representation ID: 2805
Received: 06/03/2023
Respondent: Bunwell Parish Council
The Plan only makes allowance for 3–5 windfall dwellings during the Plan period up until 2038 excluding Affordable and some self-build. We consider this insufficient for balanced expansion. Bunwell, as an example, has a serious lack of new 2/3 bedroom houses under market builds which is adversely affecting the primary school intake to the point where a nursery class has now been created. To address the housing needs balance, allocated sites must have a significant number of 2/3 bedroom commercial build houses plus onsite Affordable Housing. Offsite Affordable is an option but it must be in the village concerned
The Plan only makes allowance for 3–5 windfall dwellings during the Plan period up until 2038 excluding Affordable and some self-build. We consider this insufficient for balanced expansion. Bunwell, as an example, has a serious lack of new 2/3 bedroom houses under market builds which is adversely affecting the primary school intake to the point where a nursery class has now been created. To address the housing needs balance, allocated sites must have a significant number of 2/3 bedroom commercial build houses plus onsite Affordable Housing. Offsite Affordable is an option but it must be in the village concerned